• Evangelicals Stayed Home Last Week
• Why Did the Polls Underestimate Democrats This Time?
• The Nvidia Scandal Is the Gift That Keeps Giving--for the Democrats
• Rubio Defends Trump
• Kirsten Gillibrand's Lucky Number is 60
• Expect to Hear More from Murdoch in the Future
• Alaska Voters Like Their Top-Four Ranked-Choice Elections
Which Senate Candidates Really Overperformed?
We now know, with one exception, which Democratic Senate candidates won by the largest margins. But this metric doesn't actually say which individual candidate did the best (or worst). Sen. Jack Reed (D-RI) won by 38 points, but a random Democrat would probably have done almost as well in Rhode Island because Rhode Island is very, very blue. It is not that Reed is an exceptional candidate (although he is indeed popular with his constituents), it is that Rhode Island is chock-a-block full of Democrats with few Republicans. The Democrats could nominate a yellow dog there and the dog would still win.
A better way to look at individual candidates is to compare how well they did compared to their state's PVI. One new study did precisely that. It appears that the Democrats will win the national two-party popular vote by a staggering 14 points, 57%-43%, when all the votes are counted. This means, for example, that in a state with a PVI of R+2, a generic Republican would be expected to get 43% + 2% = 45% of the vote in the midterms, since the PVI compares a district or state to the country as a whole. A Republican who got, say, 49% last week and lost, still did 6 points better than an average Republican would have done nationally.
To look at a specific example, a generic Democrat in an R+5 state like Florida should have done 5 points worse than the national average (57%) and gotten 52% of the two-party vote statewide. Angie Nixon got only 48.5% of the vote, so she fell 3.5 points short of what a generic Democrat would have gotten. In other words, the numbers say the Democrats would have been better off nominating some random other Democrat rather than Nixon, in which case they would have narrowly won. And she ran against a weak Republican. Any talk of how well Nixon did is not based on facts. In a blue tsunami this big, she should have narrowly won, at least according to the numbers. Put in other terms, Everett Wess, who was crushed in Alabama, was actually a better candidate than Nixon, who merely lost by a little bit. Wess should have been totally obliterated in deep, deep red Alabama. Due to his skills as a candidate, he was merely crushed.
Here is a table of how individual Senate candidates did in the races where the margin was in the single digits (we are including Mary Peltola, and assuming her current margin holds, even though the AP hasn't called the race yet):
| Rank | State | Democrat | PVI | Expected % | Actual % | Diff % |
| 1 | Texas | James Talarico | R+6 | 51% | 56.2% | +5.2% |
| 2 | Mississippi | Scott Colom | R+11 | 46% | 50.1% | +4.1% |
| 3 | North Carolina | Roy Cooper | R+1 | 56% | 60.0% | +4.0% |
| 4 | Kansas | Adam Hamilton | R+8 | 49% | 52.6% | +3.6% |
| 5 (tie) | South Carolina | Annie Andrews | R+8 | 49% | 52.3% | +3.3% |
| 5 (tie) | Alabama | Everett Wess | R+15 | 42% | 45.3% | +3.3% |
| 7 | Louisiana | Jamie Davis | R+11 | 46% | 49.1% | +3.1% |
| 8 | Georgia | Jon Ossoff | R+1 | 56% | 59.0% | +3.0% |
| 9 | Iowa | Josh Turek | R+6 | 51% | 52.1% | +1.1% |
| 10 | Ohio | Sherrod Brown | R+5 | 52% | 52.5% | +0.5% |
| 11 | Nebraska | Dan Osborn | R+10 | 47% | 46.4% | -0.6% |
| 12 | Alaska | Mary Peltola | R+6 | 51% | 50.2% | -0.8% |
| 13 | New Hampshire | Chris Pappas | D+2 | 59% | 57.0% | -2.0% |
| 14 | Michigan | Abdul El-Sayed | EVEN | 57% | 53.6% | -3.4% |
| 15 | Florida | Angie Nixon | R+5 | 52% | 48.5% | -3.5% |
| 16 | Minnesota | Peggy Flanagan | D+3 | 60% | 55.2% | -4.8% |
| 17 | Maine | Troy Jackson | D+4 | 61% | 53.8% | -7.6% |
The light green candidates beat expectations. The brown ones did worse than some random Democrat would be expected to do. So, by this measure, Annie Andrews did 10.9 points better than Troy Jackson. However, when judging candidate quality, it is at least useful to consider the opponent as well. Jackson faced—and beat—one tough old bird in Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME). In South Carolina, Darline Graham is by all evidence a nice person, but a tough young bird she is not. Jackson needs to get a few bonus points for defeating a seasoned veteran, although again, Democrats (or Democrats hiding in independents' clothing) are expected to win Maine. Democrats are expected to be wiped out in South Carolina, and Andrews beat not only Graham, but also the PVI of her state and Jackson didn't. That does speak to both candidates' qualities. (V)
Evangelicals Stayed Home Last Week
There are no doubt going to be analyses of the midterms for months to come, focusing on various issues, demographics, and more. A research group at Michigan State University examined the vote in 375 counties that have large, white evangelical populations. They are spread over 15 states. They are shown in purple in the map below:
These evangelical hubs, as they are called, have about 10 million people, with about 52% of the residents being evangelicals (compared to 13% nationwide). They are mostly in the South and border states. Donald Trump got 77% of their votes in 2016, 79% in 2020, and 81% in 2024. The more they see of Trump, the more they like him. However at this rate of increase, the Republican presidential candidate won't get 100% of the evangelical vote until the 2060 election. The hubs are about 90% white and have a median income of $47,000. They also have lower educational levels than the country as a whole, with only 17% of adults having a bachelor's degree, half the national average. One area where they lead the nation is in teenage pregnancies, where they have 36 births per 1,000 girls ages 15-19, double the national level.
Only 343 of the 375 evangelical hub counties had a Senate election in 2026 (because Missouri didn't). The data showed the counties still voted Republican, but a lot less lopsidedly and with many fewer voters turning out, despite competitive races in many of the states. The 343 counties' vote was 66% of what it was in the 2024 presidential election. For the surrounding counties in those states, turnout was 78% of what it was in 2024. In other words, large numbers of evangelicals stayed home last week (or maybe they went to church, which would be unusual but not impossible on a Tuesday, but in any case, they didn't go to a polling place). If they had voted in the same numbers as the other counties in their states, that would have produced hundreds of thousands more Republican votes. Most likely, if they had turned out like the non-evangelical counties, Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith (R-MS) would have kept her job. Their absence also gave the Democrats several U.S. House seats. The Democrats might have won the Texas House no matter what, but it would have been much closer than 82D, 67R.
This study doesn't technically say anything about turnout among evangelicals in other states, but it is probably a good guess that it was depressed elsewhere as well, which could have resulted in Democrats winning tight races they would otherwise have lost. There is some evidence that white evangelicals wanted to send Donald Trump a message that they don't like his war or his enriching himself instead of looking out for them. Since voting for a Democrat is about 20 bridges too far, they just didn't vote this time.
To some extent, this study reinforces something we have said several times here: Democrats didn't win; Republicans lost. Democrats ignore this at their peril in 2028. Then they need to give voters something to vote for, not hope that voters will vote against Trump again. (V)
Why Did the Polls Underestimate Democrats This Time?
While we are picking over the elections some more, let's take another look at the polls. On the whole, they underestimated the Democrats this time, instead of the Republicans. The error was about 4 points, but the margin of error in state polls is generally about 4 points, so while the polls were off, they weren't really off by more than the margin of error. After all, due to the nature of random sampling, the measured value is going to be off from the true mean by more than the MoE 5% of the time (two sigma). That's just math. There is nothing anyone can do to fix that other than having a bigger sample, which costs more money.
Here is a graph showing the known historical polling errors in polls from 1998 to 2024 and the average of all the quality polls in the 3 weeks before Election Day this year:
Note that by averaging polls over 3 weeks, the average is going to miss last-minute changes and so probably be worse than using only polls from the last week. On the other hand, using only polls from the last week would mean less data in the average, thus being more accurate but less precise.
Interestingly, the spread was huge. Democrats beat the polling average in 18 of the 22 races examined. Oddly enough, the pollsters did the worst in the states most closely watched. The polls underestimated Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-GA) by 10 points whereas they missed Adam Hamilton by only 1 point and overestimated the three independent Senate candidates by quite a bit. Here is the breakdown by candidate:
What went wrong? One can dig deeper and try to see if there were methodological errors that created the error, rather than unlucky samples. For one thing, there appeared to be a lot of movement toward the Democrats in the final week. If some organization had run a poll on Nov. 2, it might have been much better than a poll taken a week earlier. But no one did (because it couldn't be published until after Election Day, so what's the point?). Maybe there were "shy Democrats" who were embarrassed to say they were going to vote for Troy Jackson or Annie Andrews? Maybe something else?
G. Elliott Morris, who is competing to be the new Nate Silver, took a deep look at the data and came to some tentative conclusions. What did he find?
The generic House polls before the elections had the Democrats up by 9-11 points, depending on the poll. They won by 14 points. The polls did see and correctly predict a blue wave, but it was bigger than expected. Why did the polls miss this?
From examining the data in Morris' own Verasight polls and other high-quality polls, it appears that the demographics of the people sampled matches the population at large well. In other words, it wasn't that Democrats refused to answer the pollsters' calls or text messages out of fear of jinxing the results by making the election look like a done deal so Democrats wouldn't bother to vote. The number of Democrats who did the surveys was in line with the percentage of Democrats in the country.>
So the problem was elsewhere. Was it the undecideds finally making up their minds? Maybe, but as Election Day approaches, almost all pollsters switch to a "likely voter" model rather than a "registered voter" model because it is well known that a substantial fraction of registered voters simply don't vote, even though they could. Each pollster has a secret sauce for trying to guess (and "guess" is definitely the operative word here) who is going to vote. One way is to ask the voter: "Are you going to vote?" Turns out that question isn't actually a good indicator because people are loathe to tell a pollster "Nah, voting isn't important and I have other stuff to do this week."
Some pollsters use other data where they can. In some states, lists of who actually voted in each election are available for sale. People can also be asked specifically: "Did you vote in 2024?" and "Did you vote in the 2022 midterms during the Biden administration?" Interestingly enough, people don't often lie about specific facts like that. So some pollsters use past voting behavior as a key element in their prediction of who will actually vote.
Morris' conclusion from studying the data is that while the sample had the correct number of Democrats in it, the guess about who would likely vote was off. He concluded that while people who voted for Kamala Harris turned out at the expected rate of 85%, Donald Trump voters turned out less than expected. This agrees with the above item about evangelicals. Lower Republican turnout than normal and expected was part of the problem. The pollsters expected Republicans to show up in their usual numbers and they didn't.
A second thing Morris learned from the data is that voters who did not vote in 2024 (in some cases because they were too young) skewed very heavily Democratic, something like 75% to 25%. Pollsters have to make a guess about what people without a voting history will do and they underestimated how many voters were so angry about the state of the country that they actually voted in a midterm (and again, some were too young to vote last time and were damn sure to make their first vote a good one). Infrequent voters also swung hard to the Democrats.
So Morris' conclusion is that the models for guessing who would vote were off. Young voters and marginal voters showed up in great numbers to vote for the Democrats, much more than anyone expected. Marginal voters are flaky and can shift radically from one election to another. Nonresponse bias wasn't a problem. His advice to pollsters going forward is this: First, when signs show that the out party is surging, weight the intention-to-vote question more heavily than usual. They really mean it this time. Second, forcing the presumed electorate (who is allowed to vote) to the 2024 model was fine. The problem was which of the eligible voters actually voted. Work on a better algorithm. Third, the pollsters could publish a range of results based on different turnout assumptions. In other words, if 70% of the 2024 voters vote, we get these results. But if 75% of the 2024 voters vote, we get these other results. And if by some miracle, 80% of the 2024 voters get up, we get these other results. This is another way to do stress testing. Political junkies would like this and understand it, but many people who hated math in school might be very confused by it. What's a pollster to do? (V)
The Nvidia Scandal Is the Gift That Keeps Giving--for the Democrats
A really good scandal has sex, money, power and a foreign spy. Nvidia Mobilier has everything. It is going to hang around for a while and be a headache for Donald Trump for months to come. The nature of what actually happened was quite unclear in the beginning, but it is beginning to come more in focus. Maybe after the Democrats hold hearings starting in January we will find out.
The initial take almost everyone had was something like this: China had one of its most attractive professional spies, Alice Huang (actually Huang Le), seduce Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and then tease all kinds of confidential data from him in bed, which she then reported back to the Chinese Ministry of State Security. In this model, Alice Huang was like Vladimir Putin (formerly a Lt. Colonel in the KGB), a professional spy.
The Chinese Ministry of State Security (MSS) has plenty of professional spies, of course, but what it also does a lot is use opportunist spies. They go to someone who is active and well known in the field they want to spy on and recruit them for a specific mission. Often MSS will use carrots rather than sticks because they believe someone who REALLY REALLY wants the mission to succeed is probably going to do a better job than someone who is nervous and scared to death of being punished if he or she fails.
The initial story may not be what happened exactly. JVL at the Bulwark put together a very plausible scenario that is somewhat different. It goes like this: Jensen Huang very much wants to sell AI chips to anyone with the cash to buy them, friend and foe alike. Who cares about national security? Not his problem. The trouble is that selling advanced chips to China is illegal. Huang has "befriended" Donald Trump in a straightforward way. He had Nvidia donate $25 million to Trump's favorite ballroom. That got Trump's attention and made them buddies. But convincing the mercurial Trump to give him a waiver to bypass the law wasn't easy because Marco Rubio is wildly against selling advanced chips to China.
Enter Huang's Plan B. He got together with Alice Huang, who he knew because she is a "legitimate" customer of Nvidia, buying chips for the AI data center company, Megaspeed, which she used to run, and which she may still have influence in. Together they conspired for Megaspeed to buy chips that she could then resell to Chinese companies. Somehow, in some unexplained way, $3 billion showed up on Megaspeed's books in 2024, up from $33 million in 2023.
This could have been MSS' carrot for Alice Huang. That could have been a loan which would be converted to a grant if the mission was successful. We don't know. The free sex wasn't to seduce Jensen to accidentally give away secrets. It was his reward for doing business with Alice. In this scenario, Jensen and Alice aren't adversaries at all. They are partners trying to get around U.S. export laws. Jensen knows that being duped by an attractive Chinese woman makes him look stupid for thinking with a part of his body other than his brain. But he also knows actively plotting with a Chinese spy to intentionally violate U.S. export laws is 100x worse and is definitely multiple felonies, possibly including treason. That's why he quit. He wanted to try to avoid being in the firing line when the Democrats start investigating this in January. It won't work, but what else could he do now that the chips are out of the bag?
Is this theory correct? It seems to make sense, because Jensen really wants to be able to sell chips to the gigantic Chinese market and U.S. laws prohibit that. So he is running multiple plans simultaneously, bribing Trump, collaborating with a Chinese spy, and maybe more. Who knows? Maybe CIA Director John Ratcliffe, a seasoned pro, knows, but he is certainly not going to talk about it.
But there is more to this story and that is what the Democrats will start with. U.S. intelligence agencies knew that Nvidia had been reporting that 22% of its sales were going to tiny Singapore. Huh? Then last year they changed the way they reported foreign sales to hide the sales to Singapore. This suggests that Jensen Huang knew that U.S. intelligence smelled a rat here and he was trying to cover his tracks.
The Dept. of Commerce had the information from the intelligence agencies and was investigating why 22% of the sales of the top chips were going to Singapore. Then suddenly, someone high up in government transferred the investigation to Todd Blanche's Department of "Justice" where it was immediately killed.
Who done it? Was this Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick, acting on his own? It could have been. He has been actively rewriting the export rules for advanced tech, in a manner that would coincidentally mean a windfall for the company he formerly led, Cantor Fitzgerald, which made him worth $7 billion. Cantor is now run by his sons.
Or maybe the order to kill the investigation came from someone even higher up the totem pole than Lutnick. There aren't a lot of people higher up than a cabinet secretary. Although $25 million is peanuts for Donald Trump, it does at least get you small favors. The way things work, Lutnick was not actually carrying out the investigation personally. DoC employees were doing that. It won't be hard for the incoming chairman of the House Oversight Committee, Rep. Robert Garcia (D-CA), to find out who was actually managing the investigation and invite that person over to the Hill for tea and a couple of questions. Like, ferinstance:
- What had you already discovered when the investigation stopped?
- Why did you suddenly stop the investigation? Did someone give you orders? Who?
- Knowing what you knew then, why didn't the Department blacklist Megaspeed?
Trump is going to travel to China this week. Chinese President Xi Jinping will surely roll out the red carpet, stroke Trump's ego, and maybe give him some made-up Peace Award. It is doubtful Trump will ask any difficult questions or make any threats. He's too (orange) chicken for that.
A couple of Republicans want to investigate Lutnick right now, but there isn't really enough time left in the 119th Congress to do a thorough job. The real work will begin in January when the Democrats take over.
Meanwhile, no story about the administration is good without a little grift. It's part of the package. Here is the stock price for Nvidia (NVDA) for the past 6 months:
The high point of the NVDA stock was $240.68. Friday, it closed at $162.85. That's 32% off the high in 6 weeks. Now, you might be thinking: "With this scandal going full bore, naturally some nervous Nellies will be selling their stock." But look closely and notice the decline began on Oct. 5, 2026. The Times story about Alice Huang was published Oct 29, 2026. That is 24 days after the Nvidia stock price started its precipitous drop. There was no public news about Nvidia on Oct. 5 that might have caused its stock to plunge, but if any wealthy insiders knew about what was about to come out, they could have made bank by shorting NVDA big time. The large surge in selling NVDA then could have triggered the price drop. Just askin' questions, that's all. We question, you decide. (V)
Rubio Defends Trump
Marco Rubio gave a speech at a Federalist Society event Friday. Some people were expecting him to trash Donald Trump and the war in Iran and maybe even resign so he could campaign for president full time now. Not only did he not trash Trump and not resign, but he doubled down on supporting Trump. Does he really want to run in the "I-support-Trump-and-the war" lane? How does that speak to his political judgment?
Rubio gave a ferocious defense of the administration, including sinking "drug boats," capturing the former president of Venezuela, and the campaign against immigrants. Is he trying to out-Vance JD Vance?
He also defended the war in Iran, saying Iran is behind every problem in the Middle East and it had to be put back in its box. This seems a bit odd since Vance is not-so-gradually trying to back off from the war and say he was against it from the start. Does this mean Rubio wants to run to Vance's right? That's not the obvious place for him. He isn't venal and vengeful enough to get away with that.
Rubio also dissed the very concept of international law. He said: "It [international law] is a function of the people who control the official organs of global governance... and an instrument to advance their interest under the pretense of universal principles." So things like the territorial integrity of sovereign states, not attacking other countries except in self-defense, freedom of the seas holds for everyone, treaties are binding on the signatories, and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights are garbage tossed out by global elites to maintain their power? Does he even know how institutions like the U.N., the World Bank, and the International Monetary Fund were created and why? (Hint: The U.S. championed all of them after World War II.)
Rubio even quoted the Roman general Pompey, who said: "Stop quoting laws to men with swords," because he didn't dare repeat Chairman Mao's quote: "Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun." Why didn't he just come out and say the Constitution and the rule of law are for sissies? That REAL men believe: "Might is right." Does he really want to defend that during the campaign? Of course, both Vance and Gov. Ron DeSantis (R-FL) may congratulate him for hitting the nail on the head and add: "There are no rights. There is only power." That might work with MAGA voters, but will it fly with the Texans who voted for Sen.-elect James Talarico (D)?
Rubio also addressed the war in Iran, saying: "Believe me, no war is popular. Right now, frankly, the economic pain that we are inflicting on that regime is so great that there's no need for military action because we've weakened them so much. But I think victory is ensuring that they never have a nuclear weapon." Huh? He forgot to mention that Iran now owns the Strait of Hormuz and will reap billions of dollars from tolls it will place on all ships exiting the Strait. That money can be used to repair the country and buy whatever weapons and bomb-building equipment it wants from its ally, China.
He did make a joke; speaking to a room full of lawyers and law students, he said: "On election night there was a congressman that said we all needed to lawyer up, so here we are." That was a reference to Robert Garcia's telling members of the administration that he plans to investigate the hell out of them. Within a couple of months, Rubio may discover that this was not a good joke. (V)
Kirsten Gillibrand's Lucky Number is 60
It looks like Mary Peltola will win the Alaska Senate race, giving the Democrats 56 Senate seats. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) has signed up for a second term as chair of the DSCC. She is dreaming of getting 60 Democratic senators—which is enough to invoke cloture and stop a filibuster—without having to slay the beast. We had an item last week looking at the 2028 Senate from a defensive standpoint for the Democrats, namely: Could they lose control of the Senate then? Gillibrand is looking at the 2028 Senate from an offense point of view. Could the Democrats actually get to 60?
Here is her reasoning. First, it is a generally favorable map for the Democrats, with not many vulnerable Democrats up. Sen. John Fetterman (D?-PA) is up, but he has already drawn two primary challengers and there probably will be more. We cannot conceive of Gillibrand spending any money to bail out Fetterman—assuming he even runs, which he might not. Most of the Democrats up are in blue states (see list in page linked to above). The only one in a red state is Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH), and he just won against an incumbent. In 2028, he will be the incumbent. Only two Democrats in swing states are up: Sen. Maggie Hassan (D-NH) and Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV). New Hampshire is a bluish-purple state and Sen.-elect Chris Pappas (D) just beat a strong opponent, former senator John Sununu (R), by 14 points, so Hassan is probably safe (certainly if the Democrat is elected president). In 2026, Latinos swung heavily toward the Democrats. If they do again in 2028, Cortez Masto, who is a Latina herself, is safe.
So in a reasonably good year, Democrats won't lose any Senate seats. Where does Gillibrand think she can pick up four more seats? The lowest hanging fruit is in Wisconsin, where Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI) is up, and North Carolina, where Sen. Ted Budd (R-NC) is up. Democrats did very well in both states last week, especially North Carolina, where Roy Cooper (D) won by 20 points. Winning those two would get the Democrats to 58 seats.
In Iowa. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA) is up. He will be 95 in 2028 and might finally decide that he is not up to doing the full Grassley (campaigning in all of Iowa's 100 counties) anymore. That would mean an open seat. Sen.-elect Josh Turek (D) just won an open seat in Iowa by 5 points. Could another Democrat do that in 2028? It is certainly conceivable. That would get the Democrats to 59.
Where would they get the 60th seat? Sen. Jerry Moran (R-KS) is up in Kansas. Sen.-elect Adam Hamilton (D), pastor of the biggest church in Kansas, won his state last week, although his opponent, Sen. Roger Marshall (R-KS), was deeply flawed. Could the Democrats find the pastor of the second-biggest church and get him to run as a Democrat using Hamilton's playbook?
Gillibrand also noted that the Democrats won a Senate seat in South Carolina last week, albeit against a weak candidate who was parachuted into the race without benefit of a primary. Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC) is up next time there. He's more popular than Lindsey Graham was, and certainly more popular than Darline Graham. So, this one strikes us as a reach. That said, we didn't expect Sen.-elect Annie Andrews (D) to win either.
Gillibrand hasn't named any other targets, but last week, Sen.-elect Julia Letlow (R) won by only 1.8 points in Louisiana. Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA) is up in 2028. About 33% of Louisiana voters are Black, more than South Carolina (26%) but less than Mississippi (38%). It could be worth a shot, and Louisiana is a cheap state to advertise in. Louisiana or South Carolina could be that 60th seat.
And there is one other—very outside—possibility. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) is up in 2028. She has a lot of problems with the current iteration of the Republican Party. It is conceivable that Gillibrand could have a woman-to-woman talk with Murkowski and say to her: "You can't stand your own party. Why don't you become an independent and caucus with us, like Angus [King, I-ME]?" With half the pigs in Iowa thrown in, Murkowski might take the deal. Donald Trump could threaten to primary her if she did this before the election, but due to Alaska's top-four ranked-choice general election, Murkowski wouldn't have to worry about not being on the November ballot. And the Democrats could field someone who (quietly) promised to drop out after making the general-election ballot, making it Murkowski, the Republican nominee, and whoever came in next. After the other candidate was eliminated, it would be Murkowski vs. the Republican, with all the Democrats and some of the Republicans backing the senator.
Is 60 seats just Gillibrand's fever dream? Two years is forever in politics, but there is a path for it. Needless to say, being able to invoke cloture all the time without having to change the Senate rules would be a godsend to the Democrats. (V)
Expect to Hear More from Murdoch in the Future
No, not Rupert Murdoch, who founded Fox News in 1996, and with Roger Ailes' help turned it into a powerhouse on the right. We are referring to one of Murdoch's sons, James Murdoch, who is center-left and becoming an increasing force in politics. Politico has a long profile of James.
James Murdoch's story is complicated. Back in 1999, Rupert divorced the second of his eventual five wives, Anna Torv, who is James' mother. Dad also put the voting shares of the News Corporation in an irrevocable trust with his four eldest children (those from marriages #1 and #2) as the beneficiaries. After a huge fight, the two daughters named in the trust wanted no part in the intrafamily battles and sold their future inheritances for $1.1 billion each. This left Lachlan and James Murdoch as beneficiaries. Rupert wanted Lachlan to take over the company and keep Fox "News" the way it was. James understood that the average age of a Fox viewer was approaching 70 and wanted to tone it down to attract younger viewers. Lachlan didn't. There was a huge and public battle and a big lawsuit.
What happened next was complicated but, in the end, Lachlan "won" and became CEO of Fox Corporation and Chairman of the News Corp., which owns Fox, The Wall Street Journal, The New York Post and hundreds of newspapers, television stations, and other media properties in the U.S., U.K., Australia and beyond.
James "lost" but got $3 billion after he sold all his stock in Murdoch's companies. He later left his job working for Dad and started building his own media empire, including buying New York magazine, Vox Media, setting up a business relationship with The Bulwark, taking stakes in the Tribeca Film Festival and Art Basel, and more. Murdoch wanted to buy The Bulwark, but CEO and publisher Sarah Longwell, who owns 35% of the stock, said that although it is open to business deals with other companies, it is not for sale. Murdoch's focus seems to be acquiring or partnering with companies with relatively liberal politics to help them. Some critics have said his goal is to provide diversions for the educated rich. Whatever it is, it is very different from Lachlan's goal of keeping Fox's cable channel going as it is.
James and his wife, Kathryn, have also started donating to centrist Democrats and liberal causes. He is a big fan of Pete Buttigieg and is likely to fund Buttigieg's entry into the 2028 presidential race. But he might also support similar somewhat-center-left Democrats to keep the progressives at bay. In this cycle, he donated $500,000 to the campaign of Gov. Josh Shapiro (D-PA). In the next cycle, he might well support multiple moderate Democrats in an attempt to defeat progressives, because he doesn't think they can win.
Murdoch wants change in politics and he seems to support three things:
- Change the rules so moderates can win (e.g., ranked-choice elections, primary reform)
- Get better candidates by supporting moderate Democrats who can win general elections
- Change the conversation from mud-throwing extremism
One thing that distinguishes James from both his father and his brother is that unlike them, he has no nostalgia for printing presses and paper media. He is all in on a digital-only future. In particular, he is always looking out for new center or center-left digital media upstarts to buy and generously fund to help them grow. (For those who are wondering, like The Bulwark, we are not for sale. At least, not for a penny less than $100 million.)
One recent project of James' is putting millions into Majority Democrats, a hybrid political action committee and Super PAC that supports young moderate and center-left Democrats, which is also supported by hedge-fund billionaire Stephen Mandel. At a recent three-day conference in Denver, some of the moderate stars were Buttigieg, Shapiro, Josh Turek and Sens. Elissa Slotkin (D-MI) and Ruben Gallego (D-AZ). Also present were Sens. Cory Booker (D-NJ) and Raphael Warnock (D-GA). One progressive consultant, who hates the idea of rich people dominating politics, called the event "a bunch of New York liberals in a Brooklyn-based lab trying to design normal candidates in middle America or latching onto existing successful candidates and taking credit for their work." Other potential 2028 presidential candidates Murdoch likes, but who weren't in Denver, are Sens. Mark Kelly (D-AZ) and Jon Ossoff (D-GA). All of these are mainstream Democrats and could be formidable presidential candidates who could win red states, as a number of Democrats did on Nov. 3.
In case you didn't read the blog yesterday, reader T.C. in Richmond made a suggestion we hadn't seen before. With a moderate presidential candidate of the type Murdoch likes and James Talarico as the vice-presidential nominee, the ticket might be able to win Texas. Without Texas, the Republicans' hopes of winning the election in 2028 are pretty close to zero. John F. Kennedy understood the importance of Texas in 1960 when he picked Lyndon B. Johnson as his running mate, despite despising Johnson, and regarding him as a vulgar, boorish crook. But boy did Kennedy want those Texas electoral votes. And he was right; they won Texas with 50.52% of the vote, despite Texas having gone for Dwight D. Eisenhower by 11 points 4 years earlier. Maybe it is time for the Democrats to have their own Southern Strategy, starting with Texas. (V)
Alaska Voters Like Their Top-Four Ranked-Choice Elections
There was a Republican-sponsored ballot measure in Alaska that would have repealed the current top-four primary system and gone back to regular partisan primaries. The AP has called the vote and said the measure was defeated. The "Yes on 2" campaign lost 54% to 46%, This is the second time in 2 years it has been defeated.
The main sponsors this time were Bernadette Wilson, the fiery Trumpist who just lost her gubernatorial bid, Judy Eledge and Ken McCarty. Wilson said she will not be deterred and is already starting work on getting it on the ballot in 2028. But in the meantime, ranked choice will be used again in 2028.
Republicans don't like ranked-choice voting because it means fiery right-wingers who could win first-past-the-post primaries with less than a majority will have to go after the second-place votes of moderates, independents and even Democrats, and they don't want to be effectively forced to moderate their fire. Alaskans like it because a majority of them are independents and don't like the idea of partisan primaries that exclude them.
The Senate election is almost over. Mary Peltola is now at 49.94% with 3% of the votes not yet counted. (V)
Previous report Next report
If you wish to contact us, please use one of these addresses. For the first two, please include your initials and city.
- questions@electoral-vote.com For questions about politics, civics, history, etc. to be answered on a Saturday
- comments@electoral-vote.com For "letters to the editor" for possible publication on a Sunday
- corrections@electoral-vote.com To tell us about typos or factual errors we should fix
- items@electoral-vote.com For general suggestions, ideas, etc.
- Guidelines for questions (Saturdays) and letters (Sundays)
To download a poster about the site to hang up, please click here.
Email a link to a friend.
---The Votemaster and Zenger
Nov14 America: You're Grounded
Nov14 Peltola Gets the Call
Nov14 Saturday Q&A
Nov13 Election Results: Corn Belt Gets Another Democratic Governor
Nov13 Scandal of the Week: The Nvidia Story Isn't Going Away
Nov13 Legal News: With a Bunch of Blue AGs, There Are Going to Be Some Changes around Here
Nov13 Project 2027, Part II: Time To Put This Cow out to Pasture
Nov13 I Read the News Today, Oh Boy: The Great Rockwood Flood of 1919... Was Made of Chocolate
Nov13 This Week in Schadenfreude: Soldier Takes the Wood to Hegseth
Nov13 This Week in Freudenfreude: Nobody's Gonna Paint Baby Into a Corner
Nov12 It's Colom in Mississippi
Nov12 Another Republican Is Caught with His Pants Down
Nov12 Democrats Will Run the 2028 Elections
Nov12 The Democrats Have Their Sights Trained on Kristi Noem
Nov12 Democrats Need a Lawyer
Nov12 Measles Is Not Measly Anymore
Nov12 A Second Challenger to Fetterman Is Gearing Up
Nov11 House Republicans Choose Jordan as Their Next Leader
Nov11 A Few More Election Updates
Nov11 Winners of the 2026 Midterms
Nov11 Project 2027, Part I: Impeachment
Nov10 A Few Election Updates
Nov10 Trump Gon' Trump, Part I: Cue the Election Denial
Nov10 Trump Gon' Trump, Part II: White Power
Nov10 Legal Bytes: Schadenfreude Edition
Nov10 Local Bytes: Deep in the Heart of Texas
Nov09 It Was a Quarter-Century Flood
Nov09 Democrats Will Probably Have 30 Governorships in January
Nov09 Democrats Also Won Downballot
Nov09 Ballot Measures: The Voters Decide
Nov09 Will the Electoral College Go the Way of the Rotten Boroughs?
Nov09 How Long Can the Democrats Hold the Senate?
Nov09 All of a Sudden, 2028 Looks Different
Nov09 The Polls Got the Direction Right but Underestimated the Democrats' Performance
Nov08 Sunday Mailbag
Nov07 The First Head Rolls
Nov07 Saturday Q&A
Nov07 Reader Question of the Week:
Nov06 TrumpWatch 2026: The Rats Are Preparing to Flee the Titanic
Nov06 Election Results: Tuesday Was a Good Night to Be a Challenger
Nov06 National Bytes: Has the Trump Presidency Entered a New Phase?
Nov06 The Memes: Was It 9/11 or 11/9?
Nov06 I Read the News Today, Oh Boy: The French General Napoleon Tried to Flee Europe after Waterloo
Nov06 This Week in Schadenfreude: Laura Loomer Does Her Best Chernobyl Impression
Nov06 This Week in Freudenfreude: Maybe the Apocalypse Is Not Nigh, After All
Nov05 The End of an Era
Nov05 The Knives Are Out
Nov05 More Money Was Spent on This Midterm Than Any Other in History
Nov05 It Smells Musky Here
