• Too Little, Too Late: Tech Bros Offer up a (Sorta) Mea Culpa
• Legal News: The NPVIC Is Not Unconstitutional, Per Se
• I Read the News Today, Oh Boy: There Are Other Games in Politics besides Chess (e.g., Poker)
• This Week in Schadenfreude: Vox Populi Trumps, Well, Vox Trumpuli
• This Week in Freudenfreude: An Ad Hoc "Resistance" Emerges in the Senate
This weekend is going to be non-politics questions. If you've got 'em, send em to us at
questions@electoral-vote.com.
Also, we regret that this is late again. End-of-semester means "spread thin," and on top of that there were a couple of
medium-ish earthquakes last night (the was a 4.2 close-by and a 5.1 farther away). Staff Canine Tuco was not pleased, to
say the least.
The Trilateral Summit: Trump, Xi, Putin Largely Maintain the Status Quo
Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping have concluded their much ballyhooed summit. Although right-wing media, and even some non-right-wing media, are describing it as "historic," not that much was accomplished. Still, we feel like we have to write it up, so here are the 11 biggest storylines, as we see them:
- The Good News: The most positive thing to come out of the summit is that
all three countries declared an interest in getting rid of nuclear weapons. A brief
joint statement
released by all three leaders includes this bullet point:
The three heads of state reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. The three countries will conduct a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons.
This is a pretty small piece of good news, however, because it's very easy to agree to talk about nuclear weapons. It is much harder to actually agree on a course of action. The last nuclear arms treaty, New START, was signed 16 years ago by Barack Obama. Trump allowed it to expire, because... it was signed by Barack Obama. Undoubtedly, a talented negotiator like Trump, aided by very capable emissaries like Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, will be able to come up with something better. Just as soon as they solve the situation in Israel. And the one in Ukraine. - The Bad News: Speaking of Ukraine, the three leaders also "plan to increase the production
and supply of refined petroleum products for the benefit of all nations" and they "reaffirmed the importance of stable energy
flows," according to the joint statement. Exactly what this means is not clear. But the only plausible explanation is
that Trump has agreed, or tentatively agreed, to further weaken the limits that have been placed on Russian oil sales,
which were a response to its war on Ukraine.
- Putin Gladhands Trump: Just in case there was any doubt that Putin was buttering Trump
up, Trump put such thinking to rest when he greeted the Russian with
great warmth,
and later said "He's my friend" and "We've had a great relationship for many years. We knew each other for a long time,
and I think a lot of wonderful things can come out of this." If Trump hasn't figured out, this far into his political
career, that Putin is most certainly not his friend, then he never will. Meanwhile, even many Republicans
are steaming
over Trump's conduct, and his willingness to sacrifice Ukraine in service of his "friendship" with Putin, or in a (not
likely to work) effort to lower gas prices.
- "Reforming" the U.N.: The joint statement also asserts that the three nations are
"committed to reform the UN so that the UN can respond more effectively to global challenges and conform to its
fundamental mission of international peace and security." We have not seen a single word, from any source, that
explains what that means. It is improbable, however, that three of the five permanent members of the Security Council
are looking to weaken the power of the strongest nations, or to make it easier for the U.N. to hold strong nations
accountable for misconduct.
- Down with the ICC: The joint statement also had a shot across the bow of the International
Criminal Court, decreeing that "respect for immunities of State officials are of paramount importance, and concurred
that the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction." It is hardly a surprise
that the trio does not much care for the ICC. Putin has a warrant out for his arrest, and Trump probably would, too, if
the U.S. was a signatory to the Rome Statute. Meanwhile, none of the three has any interest in surrendering even a
microgram of their nation's sovereignty to an international body, nor in creating even the slightest possibility
that they might be held accountable for their misdeeds.
- The G-3: We've had questions about whether it's true that this trio really is thinking
about dividing the world up into three spheres of influence, or if that's just something that we thought of. The spheres
of influence thing is actually implicit in the strategic doctrines of the three leaders: Xi has always made clear he
wants to dominate Asia, Putin has literally conquered parts of Europe and has made no secret of his desire for more,
and Trump wants to pull the U.S. out of those places as much as is possible, while at the same time he has embraced
what is called the Donroe Doctrine, which is basically an aggressive re-affirmation of the Monroe Doctrine that the
Americas are America's. In any event, this geopolitical vision has been written about widely (see
here
for one example; a lot of the others are behind hard paywalls). It is clear that this week's summit was not Yalta 2.0,
as many had feared. However, agreeing that the U.N. needs to be "reformed" and that the ICC may be guilty of abusing its
jurisdiction, could certainly be the starting point for trying to create a G-3 that will rule the world.
- Xi Wins: Though little of substance was accomplished, Xi nonetheless came out of it a winner.
He was given the honor of hosting the tête-à-tête, which implies that his nation is the most important
of the three, and that he is the most important leader of the three. And in case anybody missed it, the table at which
the three men sat while talking was set up to make clear who is the alpha dog:
That's almost comically large. - Putin Wins: Putin is a winner here, too, since being one of the invitees implies that he
and his nation are on par with the world's two great powers. Russia is not actually on par with China or the U.S. in any
meaningful way, except maybe number of nukes, or possibly vodka production, but the visual is still very powerful.
That said, while Xi tends to work well with Putin, there will still a few subtle reminders that the Russian is the junior partner here. For example, Xi personally greeted Trump at the airport. When Putin arrived, however, he was greeted by Director of the General Office of the Chinese Communist Party Cai Qi:
Putin is sensitive about his height (5'7"), and nobody thinks it's a coincidence that Xi just happened to send the tallest member of his government to handle this particular duty. There's a photo floating around the Internet that makes Cai, who is actually about 6'2", look as tall as NBA player Yao Ming (7'1"). The photo's fake, but the gamesmanship is real. - Zelenskyy Loses: Volodymyr Zelenskyy wasn't even at the summit, and he still
comes up a loser. Anything that strengthens Russia and/or draws Russia and the U.S. closer, is bad for Ukraine.
That said, the European powers are outraged, and are likely to step up and provide a counterbalance. Then, the
Congress will fall under the control of the Democrats in about 6 weeks, and then maybe there will be some
relief for the Ukrainians. It is plausible that there could be enough Democratic plus Republican votes on
this issue for a veto override, if needed.
- Trump Sleeps: This appears to be literally true. There was a brief period during
Xi's speech when Trump looked to have dozed off:
The White House claimed that Trump was just reading some papers; if so, it's a neat trick to be able to read with your eyes closed. And whether Trump was literally sleeping during the summit, he was certainly sleeping metaphorically. That is to say, he appears to have gotten nothing of value for the U.S., while giving wins to both of the other leaders. This is not good diplomacy. - Priorities, Priorities: If Trump was sleeping, it may have been because he
was up all hours sending messages on his social media platform for Russophiles. For example, there was this
urgent matter
that he simply had to attend to:
I have just given a Complete and Total Pardon to the Late, Great Pete Rose, a true Baseball SUPERSTAR & LEGEND, whose record of 4,256 Career Hits will never be broken. In addition, Pete played 3,562 career games (Highest Ever!), had 1,314 Runs batted in, 160 Home Runs, a .303 Batting Average, was a 17x All-Star, 3x World Series Champion, NL MVP, World Series MVP, NL Rookie of the Year, 2x Recipient of the Gold Glove Award, Silver Slugger Award, Roberto Clemente Award, 3x NL batting champion and, just like the Great Roger Clemens, who won 354 games, was treated terribly by Major League Baseball in not allowing him to go into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Politics, I guess! Thank you for your attention to this matter. President DONALD J. TRUMP
We are not clear on the difference between a full pardon and a "Complete and Total Pardon." What we do know is that pardoning a dead man, like Rose, doesn't actually change anything. So, this probably could have waited until Trump got back to the U.S.—in contrast to his playing days, Charlie Hustle is in no rush right now.
Why 11 storylines? Because it's one more than 10.
That's it for diplomacy, Trump-style, for the moment. However, the G20 is meeting at one of Trump's resorts next month, and it is possible that Xi and/or Putin will be in attendance, to renew the bromance. The two leaders both know that they need to get while the gettin's good, because there is zero chance that the next U.S. president, regardless of what party he or she comes from, will be as easily manipulated as Trump is. Maybe Trump and Xi will also discuss the small matter of the current trade deal between the U.S. and China, which is set to expire in early January. On the other hand, maybe Trump won't find time. After all, he hasn't pardoned Shoeless Joe Jackson yet. (Z)
Too Little, Too Late: Tech Bros Offer up a (Sorta) Mea Culpa
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. That is the theme of this item.
When Donald Trump became president the second time, he put out a "for sale" sign. There were all sorts of opportunities for the ultra-rich to use their money to curry favor with the administration, whether it was buying worthless crypto, or "donating" to the inauguration celebration, or chipping in for the ballroom, or appointing one of the sons of Trump to some sort of cushy sinecure, or any other of a dozen grifts. The rewards for such support included less regulation, fast-track approval of mergers, pardons and awarding of fat (and, often, no-bid) government contracts.
This is not the first time a president has used the powers of their office for fundraising purposes. That said, Trump is different in two, or maybe, three ways. The first is how baldfaced his grift is. Past presidents have certainly taken donations for their inaugurations or their presidential libraries, but then they spent that money... on their inaugurations or their presidential libraries. Similarly, holding chichi $10,000-a-plate dinners to raise funds has become old hat, for president of both parties. But again, the money goes to the parties and to politicking. No other president has lined his own pockets. Trump certainly has, and he's pretty much willing to take whatever the rich and powerful are willing to give.
The second difference is that Trump is a litmus test guy. Every other politician knows that the rich guys kind of have to play both sides of the street, because you just never know. So, if Bill Gates donates a million bucks to Democrats, but also gives half a million to Republicans, a Barack Obama or a Joe Biden does not get their knickers in a twist. Trump most certainly does.
The third (possible) difference is that Trump seems to attract True Believers. These are the folks who give to him not just because it's good for business, but because they seem to really and truly believe in MAGA. Mike Lindell, the MyPillow guy, is one example. Richard and Elizabeth Uihlein are a second, and Timothy Mellon is a third.
The upshot here is that you have a lot of rich folks—people who have to worry a lot about things like government contracts, regulation, etc.—who are very, very deeply committed to one side of the political street. And, as of November 3, that street is by and large the wrong side of the political street. The MAGA billionaires—at least, some of them—already have serious trouble on their hands at the state level, and at least semi-serious trouble at the federal level. And things figure to get worse in 2028, as the tea leaves strongly suggest a federal Democratic trifecta is on the way.
It is therefore not too surprising that some pretty high-profile folks have suddenly had a "come to Jesus" moment in the past week or so. First out of the gate was Alex Karp, CEO of Palantir, which makes AI software and other such products. Karp donated tens of millions of dollars to Trump's PAC and to related projects. He has lambasted DEI, described Palantir as "anti-woke," and slammed the Democratic Party as "totally irresponsible."
In an interview with Politico, published last week, Karp was singing a very different tune. He said: "I've been a Democrat my whole life. I grew up in a far left environment. I know more about being a progressive than almost anybody on the planet, and I absolutely believe Palantir—all of our products are essentially progressive." He also explained that when he gives money to politicians, "I'm really not pitching Palantir. I'm actually pitching, 'What are you gonna do about economic justice in this country?'" Always good to hear from a billionaire whose #1 concern is economic justice.
Meanwhile, yesterday brought us an even more aggressive change of course, one so sudden you might well have heard the sonic boom. We speak, of course, of Elon Musk. He sat for an interview with Andrew Ross Sorkin, founder of Dealbook (you can watch the interview here, if you wish), and it was a doozy. Among the thoughts that the Tesla trillionaire shared:
- The new governor [Gina Hinojosa, D-TX] actually, I think, is going to be quite moderate. I don't think she's sort of
a far-left governor. And based on everything I've heard about her, I think things will be fine in Texas with Gina as
governor.
- I'm ideologically quite moderate... I don't think I have any kind of extreme political views. I mean, I'm not MAGA.
Well, at least I'm not—I'm not sure what MAGA means, but if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of
policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don't have that.
- I do think that it's good to have some balance of power, not have the, as a general rule, not have the presidency, Senate, and House all be of the same party. So my goal, and I did mention this on X, was that I think we want to have at least one of either the presidency, the House, or the Senate be of the other party.
That's some black-belt-level gaslighting there. We presume that people will remember he spent half a billion dollars trying to elect Republicans this cycle, including almost $200 million in a failed effort to have his own, personal Texas U.S. Senator. They will also remember that the "quite moderate" Musk has regularly shared white supremacist content on his social media platform. And we presume they will remember that he was not at all a fan of checks and balances when he was taking an axe to the government as leader of DOGE.
As to whether he's MAGA or not, it's not hard to find the video of the time that Musk appeared at a Trump rally in a custom-made black "Make America Great Again" hat, and told the crowd: "I'm not just MAGA, I'm dark, gothic MAGA." And, as long as we're on the subject of hats, let us also not forget this little delight that Musk whipped up:
If that is not "blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party," we're not quite sure what is.
There are plenty of other big-time Trump donors, many of them in crypto, who are suddenly re-discovering their love for Democrats, as well.
Politicians love them some big, easy-to-land donations. And that certainly includes Democrats. So, it could be that if the 0.1% get out their checkbooks, and write some "We're really, REALLY sorry"-sized checks, all will be forgiven. But maybe not. Certainly, Musk, et al., at least have very good reason to be worried. The first issue, as we note above, is that they leaned so aggressively into Trump and MAGA, it's going to be hard to reverse that. The second is that a lot of the things the rich people want—AI, data centers, the ability to donate unlimited sums to politicians (i.e., Citizens United)—are very unpopular and are exactly the issues that Democrats ran on. And a third issue is that some of these billionaires, particularly Musk, are personally very, very unpopular with Democratic voters. If there is a primary, and [CANDIDATE X] says "I don't take money from Elon Musk, but my opponent [CANDIDATE Y] sure does," that could do a lot of damage (something along the lines of how AIPAC donations became toxic this cycle).
We don't know how this ends, but if some of the billionaires are neutered for a while, that is surely good for democracy. And if you throw in the permanent neutering of Elon Musk, both metaphorically and literally, then you're really on to something. (Z)
Legal News: The NPVIC Is Not Unconstitutional, Per Se
The Electoral College has long been a thorn in the side of many people who believe it undermines democracy, in that the popular vote winner of America's presidential contest doesn't always become president. As has been discussed many times here and elsewhere, it also creates an incentive to concentrate all of a candidate's resources on a small number of "swing" states, despite the fact that their population or demographics may not merit such outsized attention. All other states, meanwhile, are largely ignored by presidential candidates, since they use a winner-take-all system to award electoral votes and the results are usually a foregone conclusion. This can depress voter turnout.
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC) is a simple idea, whereby states pledge to award their electoral votes to the national popular vote winner, regardless of how their individual state votes. So, if this were in place in 2000, for example, Indiana, which voted for George W. Bush, would have awarded its electoral votes to Al Gore, the national popular vote winner. This would have resulted in Gore becoming president and we could have avoided learning about Florida's hanging chads and the Brooks Brothers riot.
So far, 18 states and D.C. have signed on, amounting to 222 electoral votes. The NPVIC takes effect once enough states sign on to get to 270 electoral votes. With the midterm election, there are five more states likely to sign on, any four of which would cross the 270 line: Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. All of these states will have a Democratic trifecta come January 2027.
There are some potential legal issues with this idea, however. And since Republicans have not fully embraced the NPVIC—although Republican-led chambers in New York, Oklahoma and Arizona joined the compact—they are likely to bring some legal challenges to its implementation. Now, if Republicans believe that Texas is really going blue, that could change their thinking on this subject, since that would put the GOP's biggest, safest repository of EVs in doubt, and might mean that a popular-vote victory is their best (and maybe only) path to winning the White House. Nonetheless, let's run through some of the potential hurdles.
The Elections Clause, in Article II, Section 1, of the U.S. Constitution, says:
Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress..."
The section goes on to detail how the electors meet and how to tally their votes, including that "they shall make a List of all the Persons voted for, and of the Number of Votes for each; which List they shall sign and certify, and transmit sealed to the Seat of the Government of the United States, directed to the President of the Senate." Given that the section allows the legislature to determine the "manner" in which the electors are appointed, many argue that electors can be instructed to vote for the winner of the national popular vote, regardless of the state's results. The Supreme Court has definitely held that the legislature can require electors to vote based on the state's popular vote. But it's still an open question whether the legislature can require electors to ignore the state's popular vote and only follow the national vote.
There's also the Compact Clause of Article I, Section X. However, if this came into play due to lawsuits, it would not prohibit states from entering into the NPVIC. It would just require Congressional approval. Interestingly, the president's sign-off is probably not required, though John Roberts and his band of merry men (and one merry woman) would undoubtedly get the final say.
Aside from the possibility of legal challenges, there are also other arguments for choosing less dramatic reforms to the current system. Theodore Johnson proposes that the problems the NPVIC is designed to address can be fixed with a simpler, more straightforward solution. The issue with the NPVIC is it requires state legislatures to, in some cases, ignore their residents' choice for president. While the U.S. elects a president to serve the nation, it's still a collection of states with their own sovereignty and plenary power. One can imagine that residents of the states that choose a president who doesn't win the national popular vote might not be so thrilled to have their votes cast for someone else.
Johnson proposes that instead of ignoring those votes, states should elevate them and award their electoral votes proportionally, instead of winner-take-all. In other words, if Jon Ossoff wins 60% of the vote in California and Marco Rubio wins 40%, then Jon Ossoff gets 60% of the votes, while the 40% minority still gets a voice in the presidential contest, as they will end up awarding about 21 EVs to Rubio. This approach would require candidates to campaign in more states and districts, and would also ensures that the winning candidate has a majority of the nation's voting population. As Johnson notes, "That approach would mean that when choosing a president, both people and states—twin pillars of the republic—count."
This alternative approach is not perfect, mind you. Since EVs would be rounded, it could produce wonky results in very close elections (say, like the one in 1960). Further, while candidates would no longer be incentivized to lavish most of their attention on Michigan and Nevada, they would be incentivized to focus almost entirely on high-population urban areas.
That said, the political problem with the NPVIC—which the folks who created the idea did not anticipate—is that if and when it comes into force, it will do so almost entirely with the backing of blue states. Except for Oklahoma, even those states where a Republican legislature approved the pact are blue now. The primary value of the alternative approach, then, might be as a compromise measure. Democrats could say: "We've got he NPVIC, and we think we can defend it in court, but we are also willing to enact the alternative if Republicans will support it."
We're putting the cart ahead of the horse here a little, since the NPVIC hasn't actually been approved by the necessary number of states, nor have Republicans made clear they will resist it. Still, it can't hurt to know the lay of the land as this story unfolds next year. (L & Z)
I Read the News Today, Oh Boy: There Are Other Games in Politics besides Chess (e.g., Poker)
We often write about 3-D chess around here. But recently, (Z) delivered his lecture on the end of World War II, which was a reminder that while Harry S. Truman may have played metaphorical chess sometimes, he definitely played metaphorical poker. Poker was, in fact, his very favorite leisure-time activity, and it certainly shaped his thinking in other areas, most notably the use of the atomic bombs.
Most readers will know that, once the Trinity test was successful, Truman had two bombs at his disposal. He most certainly saw that as drawing a pair of aces, which is a strong hand in poker, but is not a certain winner. So, he developed a strategy not dissimilar to how he would have played "pocket rockets" (though his game was seven-card stud, not the currently much more popular Texas Hold 'em). In short, the strategy was angry speech, drop bomb, second angry speech, drop second bomb very shortly thereafter.
Harry S. has been much criticized for those choices, particularly dropping the second bomb so quickly. We are not here to wade into that debate, only to note that this was the way he played his pair of aces. That is to say, dropping the second bomb quickly was, in poker terms, a bluff. He was trying to represent a better hand than he actually had (i.e., far more than two bombs; so many that he could afford to drop nukes every day if need be). Whether the second bomb was necessary or not can never be known for certain. What we can know is that Japan surrendered 5 days after the second bomb was dropped (August 9 was Nagasaki, August 14 was V-J Day, at least in the U.S.).
And with the little history (and poker) lesson out of the way, here are the two hints we gave last week: (1) "we thought for sure we'd use the phrase 'hot potato' in a headline, but... there's none where that would make sense" and (2) "We really expected to use 'poker' in a headline, but it did not work. We hoped to use 'tortilla,' but didn't really think it would be plausible (and it wasn't)."
And here is the solution, courtesy of reader G.A. in North Bay, ON, Canada:
This week's theme is chips.
- Election Results: Corn Belt Gets Another Democratic Governor—Corn Chips
- Scandal of the Week: The Nvidia Story Isn't Going Away—Nvidia Chips
- Legal News: With a Bunch of Blue AGs, There Are Going to Be Some Changes around Here—Blue Chips
- Project 2027, Part II: Time To Put This Cow out to Pasture—Cow Chips
- I Read the News Today, Oh Boy: The Great Rockwood Flood of 1919... Was Made of Chocolate—Chocolate Chips
- This Week in Schadenfreude: Soldier Takes the Wood to Hegseth—Wood Chips
- This Week in Freudenfreude: Nobody's Gonna Paint Baby Into a Corner—Paint Chips
Yes! Of course, "potato" and "tortilla" are also kinds of chips. And we finally got "poker" in there with this headline.
Here are the first 60 readers to get it right:
|
|
The 60th correct response was received at 9:54 a.m. PT on Saturday.
For this week's theme, it relies on multiple words in each headline, and it's in the category Language. For a hint, we'll rely on an old chestnut: "When in Rome..."
If you have a guess, send it to comments@electoral-vote.com with subject line November 20 Headlines. (Z)
This Week in Schadenfreude: Vox Populi Trumps, Well, Vox Trumpuli
The White House is trying to keep this as quiet as possible, for obvious reasons, and is using the summit (see above) as cover to try to sneak it in under the radar. But yesterday, the Department of Justice moved to dismiss the lawsuit it filed in Alaska, the one endeavoring to block the election of Sen.-elect Mary Peltola (D).
The official reason the suit is being dismissed is that it requested that fake Dan Sullivan ballots be set aside, and now that the ballots have been counted, that is no longer possible. This, of course, is nonsense. First, the DoJ could have filed an amended complaint. Second, it's still entirely plausible to tell the fake Sullivan ballots from the real Sullivan ballots (Hint: The fake Sullivan ballots have him ranked higher than the real Sullivan).
The real reason the suit is being filed is that it has nowhere to go, on multiple levels. To start, and as both we and many judges have noted, there's no legal basis for federal interference of this sort. Beyond that, Peltola is going to end up winning by about 13,000 votes. That is not only more than the fake Sullivan got (4,765), it's more than the fake Sullivan AND the fourth guy, Gerald Heikes, got (Heikes collected 6,105 votes, for a total of about 11,000 between him and the fake Sullivan). And finally, Gov.-elect Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins (D) won his race by a considerably larger margin than Peltola won hers. It's clear that, at least this year, there were a lot of blue voters in Alaska (and not because they were cold).
What this means, big-picture wise, is that while Donald Trump and his houseboy AG Todd Blanche threatened
lawsuits a-plenty once the ballots were in, they ended up only filing one, and that one collapsed in epic fashion.
Like, this was the Hindenburg of election-challenge lawsuits. And what made it all possible was that people
got out and voted. We wrote many times that the very best defense against shenanigans was for the results to be
so lopsided as to be beyond all doubt and, by and large, they were. That meant a big, black eye for both Trump
and Blanche, and those two anti-democratic fellows deserve every bit of schadenfreude they reap as a result. (Z)
This Week in Freudenfreude: An Ad Hoc "Resistance" Emerges in the Senate
Today, the Senate is scheduled to adjourn, and the members will leave Washington for a weeklong Thanksgiving break. According to the current calendar, they are back on November 30, they'll work for 15 more days (through Friday, December 18), and then the 119th session of the United States Senate will be in the history books.
What this means is that if Donald Trump is going to get problematic nominees approved by the Republican majority, time is running out. It requires some amount of time to hold hearings, and the members are presumably also going to have to spend some time on a budget resolution, even if it's just kicking the can. Yes, Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-SD) could hold them for some extra days, but there aren't too many of them left, even if he's willing to say "sorry, no Christmas/Hanukkah for you this year." Plus, the updated calendar was released a week ago, when Thune already knew full well the post-election score. So, don't bet on anything much beyond 15 more days of work.
Meanwhile, a very clear storyline has presented itself this week, as various members of the Senate have blocked and/or defeated several Trump nominees. Here is a rundown:
- Heidi Overton: As we briefly noted earlier this week, on Monday, Republicans on the Senate
Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee
killed
the nomination of Heidi Overton to lead the FDA before it even came up for a vote. It would appear that there is no longer a
position on abortion pills that is acceptable to the full range of Republican senators, with Lisa Murkowski (AK) unhappy with
the harshness of Overton's views, while Josh Hawley (MO) thought Overton was far too permissive.
- Jim O'Neill: Later on Monday, Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-LA) voted against Jim O'Neill to
lead the National Science Foundation. That keeps the nomination from coming to the floor of the Senate, and effectively
kills it.
- T. Elliot Gaiser: On Tuesday, Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) did not return his "blue slip," and so
blocked
T. Elliot Gaiser from being confirmed for a seat on the U.S. District Court in the Northern District of Texas.
Cornyn's official reason is that he is only open to judges born in Texas (Gaiser was born in Ohio). Conveniently,
Cornyn had a judge born in Texas in mind, and the White House ignored him.
- Michael LoSapio: Yesterday, both Ron Wyden (D-OR) and Thom Tillis (R-NC) placed holds on the nomination of Michael LoSapio to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency. Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT) only asks nominees two questions these days: (1) Who won the presidential election of 2020? and (2) Was the Capitol attacked on Jan. 6, 2021? So, LoSapio should have known those were coming. Nonetheless, he choked on the latter question, and after hemming and hawing, said that the Capitol was not, in fact, attacked. Wyden and Tillis placed the holds shortly thereafter.
Nominally speaking, Senate Judiciary Chair Chuck Grassley (R-IA) could announce that blue slips don't matter anymore, and that he's going to ram through the Gaiser nomination anyhow. But he's not likely to do that, and even if he did, the nomination might fail because blue-slip-loving Republicans might not want to set that precedent right before losing control of the upper chamber. Meanwhile, placing a hold on a nomination just means that the senator won't agree to a voice vote, and is going to force the nomination to go through the whole process of cloture and debate. There's just not time for that, so LoSapio's nomination is effectively dead, unless Thune thinks it's a top, top priority.
The reason that this is freudenfreude is that, in rejecting four problematic nominees in less than a week, the senators are finally doing their jobs, which is great news. We actually tend to share the view of the late Lindsey Graham that, by and large, a president should be able to put their own team in place. That said, the Senate does have a duty to make sure that there aren't any really incompetent or corrupt nominees who get approved. And Trump nominates a well-above-average number of people who are incompetent, corrupt, or both. By and large, the GOP senators have looked the other way. Now, they aren't.
We recognize, of course, that the members driving the events of this week are almost entirely Democrats and/or Republicans who will be unemployed as of January 3. Still, maybe this is the start of something, as the non-MAGA Republicans in the upper chamber (of which there are many) finally begin to reassert themselves. Also, the Republicans 53-47 edge will change about Dec. 15 to 52-48 when Sen.-elect Sherrod Brown (D-OH) will be sworn in. He won a special election and winners of special elections are sworn in as soon as the results are certified. At very least, a quartet of very poor nominees was defeated, and there's only a few weeks left until a party with an overwhelming majority, and whose members will not be cowed by Trump, takes over. So, the day of no more Pete Hegseths and no more Robert Kennedys will soon be upon us, if it's not already here.
Have a good weekend, all! (Z)
Previous report Next report
If you wish to contact us, please use one of these addresses. For the first two, please include your initials and city.
- questions@electoral-vote.com For questions about politics, civics, history, etc. to be answered on a Saturday
- comments@electoral-vote.com For "letters to the editor" for possible publication on a Sunday
- corrections@electoral-vote.com To tell us about typos or factual errors we should fix
- items@electoral-vote.com For general suggestions, ideas, etc.
- Guidelines for questions (Saturdays) and letters (Sundays)
To download a poster about the site to hang up, please click here.
Email a link to a friend.
---The Votemaster and Zenger
Nov19 The Shift Was Gigantic Almost Everywhere...
Nov19 ...Even in the State Supreme Court Elections
Nov19 What Did the Parties Really Think Was Important?
Nov19 Lisa Cook Won't Go to Her (Kangaroo Court) Hearing
Nov19 The Administration Is Intimidating Robert Garcia--and He is Intimidating Right Back
Nov19 Introducing the Vibes Index
Nov18 AP Makes the Call in Alaska
Nov18 Outage Outrage
Nov18 Corruption, Thy Name Is Trump
Nov18 Political Bytes: Chuck's It
Nov17 Is Trump Grounded?
Nov17 The 2028 Presidential Race, Part I: Vance Can't Dance?
Nov17 The 2028 Presidential Race, Part II: Here's to the Power of Positive Delusion
Nov17 Alaska Mushes Toward the Finish
Nov17 Local Bytes, 2026 Post-Election Edition, Part I: Feeling Heard
Nov16 Which Senate Candidates Really Overperformed?
Nov16 Evangelicals Stayed Home Last Week
Nov16 Why Did the Polls Underestimate Democrats This Time?
Nov16 The Nvidia Scandal Is the Gift That Keeps Giving--for the Democrats
Nov16 Rubio Defends Trump
Nov16 Kirsten Gillibrand's Lucky Number is 60
Nov16 Expect to Hear More from Murdoch in the Future
Nov16 Alaska Voters Like Their Top-Four Ranked-Choice Elections
Nov15 Sunday Mailbag
Nov14 America: You're Grounded
Nov14 Peltola Gets the Call
Nov14 Saturday Q&A
Nov13 Election Results: Corn Belt Gets Another Democratic Governor
Nov13 Scandal of the Week: The Nvidia Story Isn't Going Away
Nov13 Legal News: With a Bunch of Blue AGs, There Are Going to Be Some Changes around Here
Nov13 Project 2027, Part II: Time To Put This Cow out to Pasture
Nov13 I Read the News Today, Oh Boy: The Great Rockwood Flood of 1919... Was Made of Chocolate
Nov13 This Week in Schadenfreude: Soldier Takes the Wood to Hegseth
Nov13 This Week in Freudenfreude: Nobody's Gonna Paint Baby Into a Corner
Nov12 It's Colom in Mississippi
Nov12 Another Republican Is Caught with His Pants Down
Nov12 Democrats Will Run the 2028 Elections
Nov12 The Democrats Have Their Sights Trained on Kristi Noem
Nov12 Democrats Need a Lawyer
Nov12 Measles Is Not Measly Anymore
Nov12 A Second Challenger to Fetterman Is Gearing Up
Nov11 House Republicans Choose Jordan as Their Next Leader
Nov11 A Few More Election Updates
Nov11 Winners of the 2026 Midterms
Nov11 Project 2027, Part I: Impeachment
Nov10 A Few Election Updates
Nov10 Trump Gon' Trump, Part I: Cue the Election Denial
Nov10 Trump Gon' Trump, Part II: White Power
Nov10 Legal Bytes: Schadenfreude Edition
